Home studies homework help An argument that the holocaust should be named a genocide

An argument that the holocaust should be named a genocide

InWinston Churchillwhen describing the German invasion of the Soviet Unionspoke of "a crime without a name". The book describes the implementation of Nazi policies in occupied Europeand cites earlier mass killings.

An argument that the holocaust should be named a genocide

Terminology[ edit ] According to historian Yair Auron"there can be no doubt about the fact of [Armenian] genocide itself. In this sense, the denial of the Armenian genocide is very similar to the denial of the Holocaust.

He later used it to describe what he had heard about the Armenian Genocide: It happened to the Armenians, then after the Armenians, Hitler took action. He pointed out that this phrase 1 was an oxymoron and 2 represented an invented standard of proof.

He further observed that recent British governments have not taken into account that the terms used by the British government of the time in referring to entirely anticipated the modern definition of genocide and that the drafters of the Genocide Convention had in mind when drafting the new international crime.

Turkey instead uses the words "relocation" and "immigrant", respectively. We will never accept the accusations of genocide". The Turkish government does not deny that many Armenians were killed by the Ottoman militarybut disputes the death toll, and emphasizes that there were deaths on both sides during World War I.

Another reason is the demand for reparations. The Armenian Genocide Reparations Study Group has released a study that was partly funded by Armenian advocacy organizations which includes various recommendations for how to calculate a possible reparations package.

Genocide scholar Henry C. Theriault who chaired the panel has said that the question of reparations is "obviously a pretty central one". The Turkish government position is that reparations do not need to paid for the events of Human rights historians have said that recognition by Turkey would undermine any legal defense Turkey might have to future compensation claims.

According to Fatma Muge Gocek, many Turkish journalists have viewed the issue of recognition as "an imposition on the Turkish state and society, one that would solely benefit the Armenians". In one editoral a Turkish journalist wrote "If you once acknowledge, then see what will happen next?

From demands for restitution to land However, the Armenians had neither a police force nor an army. In the late s access was granted to some archives by the Turkish government, but it appears that the material was limited and the government took a very selective approach to who was allowed to study the material.

An Argument for Outlawing Genocide Denial - Inquiries Journal

Turkey accepts that there were Armenian deaths as a result of Ottoman decisions, but states that the responsible Ottoman bureaucrats and military personnel were tried. Bernard Lewis believes that what he names the "tremendous massacres" [39] were not "a deliberate preconceived decision of the Ottoman government".

McCarthy calculated an estimate of the pre-war Armenian population, then subtracted his estimate of survivors, arriving at a figure of less thanfor Armenian casualties for the period to Dadrian [45] and professor Levon Marashlian.

They point out that there was no official statistic census in ; rather those numbers were based on the records of which were conducted during the reign of Sultan Hamid. German official Max Erwin von Scheubner-Richter wrote that fewer thanArmenians survived the genocide, the rest having been exterminated German: Armenian-Turkish relations The Turkish authorities have put forth certain conditions before attempting to reconcile with Armenia.

The borders have remained closed because the Nagorno-Karabakh dispute has not been settled to this day. To start an effective dialog, we should create a favorable political environment. The governments are responsible for the development of bilateral relations, and we have no right to delegate that responsibility to the historians.

Thus, we have proposed and we again propose to establish normal relations between our countries without preconditions. In this regard, an inter-governmental commission can be formed to discuss the outstanding issues to resolve them and maintain mutual understanding.

The Memoirs of Naim Bey and Aram Andonian Many references that cite genocidal intent use the "Talat Pasha telegrams", which are a series of documents by the Interior Minister Mehmed Talat Pashato constitute concrete evidence that the deaths were implemented as a state policy.

Pasha was tied to the "Kill every Armenian man, woman, and child without concern" order in these documents. Lewis responded that the statement was an attempt to avoid damaging Turkish-American relationships and that it included a call for Turkey to open its archives, but the former was not mentioned in the statement.

Others confirm that there have been massacres but say they avoid the use of the term Genocide.

An argument that the holocaust should be named a genocide

He resigned from the position of the chairman of the board of directors of the Institute of Turkish Studies, which he had held since As he announced, he had to resign due to the pressure of the Turkish ambassador Nabi Shensoy after he characterised the massacres of Armenians in Turkey as genocide.

Shensoy rejected the allegations. Hatem also noted, that "the resignations are in contradiction with those many requests to leave the discussion and the assessment of the Armenian Genocide to the academia instead of discussing it on the political arena that Turkey has been making.

Politicians from primarily left wing and centrist parties such as Meretz and Kadimabut also occasionally right wing parties such as Likudhave been promoting recognition and commemoration of the Armenian Genocide. This cooperation is significant since it includes activists and politicians who usually are on the opposing sides of the political spectrum.

Right-wing party Yisrael Beiteinu Israel Our Home claims that Genocide discussions would jeopardise Israel-Azerbaijan and Israel-Turkish relations and hurt close economic and military cooperation with them.Armenian Genocide denial is the act of denying the planned systematic genocide of million Armenians during World War I, conducted by the Ottoman government.

As a form of denialism, it can be compared to similar negationist historical revisionisms such as Holocaust denial and Nanking Massacre denial.

To prosecute the leaders of the Holocaust, the International Military Tribunal in Nuremberg was formed in The U.S., the UK, the Soviet Union and France each supplied two judges (a primary and an alternate) and a prosecution team for the trial.

The Holocaust “The holocaust is a Greek word (holo “whole”; caustos “burned”) which is a religious rite in which an offering was entirely consumed by fire.”(Encarta) In modern world the word holocaust refers to any widespread of human disaster, especially means slaughter of Jewish population in Germany and in German-controlled states.

Apr 09,  · The Holocaust was a genocide that consisted of the decimation of one single race, the Jews. which led to clashing beliefs. There are eight stages of genocide that pertain to the conflict in Rwanda. Finally, genocide should never be just ignored/pretend that it never happened.

followed by the argument for genocide and its counterargument.

The Holocaust - HISTORY

Genocide in Night Genocide: the deliberate and systematic extermination of an ethnic or national group. The crime against humanity, that is genocide, has plagued the world for thousands of years.

Although there have been many genocides since the beginning of time, the word "genocide&qu. “It is not just the equivalent of Holocaust denial,” Kamm goes on, “but the same fraudulent argument. It should be recognised and named for what it is: genocide denial.” BEFORE WE REVISIT “Srebrenica,” let us deal briefly with Kamm’s interesting contention that the Muslims of Bosnia and Kosovo are immune to the well-known pursuits.

Genocide - Wikipedia